Chicago Sun-Times - Neil Steinberg
Chicago Sun-Times
Home | News | Sports | Business | Entertainment | Classifieds | Columnists | Lifestyles | Ebert | Search | Archives
mobile | email edition | printer friendly | email article

Autos
Reviews & more
Homes
Homelife news
Careers
News & advice
Subscribe
Customer service

Inside News
  Today's news
  Archive
  Census
  Commentary
  Editorials
  Education
  Elections
  Lottery
  Obituaries
  Politics
  Religion
  Special sections
  Weather
  Weather cam
  War on Terror
  War in Iraq

News Columnists
  Andrade
  Brown
  Falsani
  Foster
  Greeley
  Higgins
  Jackson
  Laney
  Martire
  McNamee
  Mitchell
  Novak
  Ontiveros
  O'Rourke
  O'Sullivan
  Pickett
  Quick Takes
  Richards
  Roeper
  Roeser
  Smith
  Sneed
  Steinberg
  Steyn
  Sweet
  Washington
  Will
  Wiser
  Other Views

 

Neil Steinberg

Was Clinton really any better than Coolidge?

July 28, 2004

BY NEIL STEINBERG SUN-TIMES COLUMNIST

Opening shot

"Bill Clinton was a great president,'' my wife announced at dinner Monday night. I looked up from my rigatoni. I knew she was just giddy at the prospect of hearing him speak later that night at the Democratic Convention, and considered letting it pass. But the boys were there.

"Could you,'' I asked, "explain the logic behind that sentiment?"

She said: "He presided over a period of great prosperity.''

RELATED STORIES

SPEECHES

TODAY'S LINEUP

Today's convention theme is "A Stronger More Secure America." C-SPAN, CNN, Fox News, MSNBC and PBS will provide live coverage of these prime time speakers, with ABC, CBS and NBC airing coverage from 9 to 10 p.m.:

  • Steve Brozak, Ret. Lt. Col., USMC, House candidate from New Jersey
  • Rep. Elijah Cummings (D-Md.)

  • Cate Edwards, daughter of John Edwards

  • Elizabeth Edwards, wife of John Edwards

  • Vice presidential candidate John Edwards

  • Sen. Bob Graham (D-Fla.)

  • Jennifer Granholm, governor of Michigan

  • Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio)

  • Rep. Greg Meeks (D-N.Y.)

  • Martin O'Malley, mayor of Baltimore

  • Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.)

  • Ed Rendell, governor of Pennsylvania

  • Bill Richardson, governor of New Mexico

  • Al Sharpton

By that standard Calvin Coolidge was a great president.

"If Bill Clinton was great,'' I said, "what was Abraham Lincoln -- super-great?"

She surprised me by yielding the point. Married readers will realize how rarely that happens. But only for a few seconds. Then she returned to the fray.

"Bill Clinton is great....'' she said, "compared to the current president.''

I went back to my rigatoni.

Live! On stage!

Last week I dismissed the convention as mere theater. That was a mistake, and not just because it led to an angry confrontation with our Washington reporter, Lynn Sweet (well, she was angry; I was more stunned). Having tuned in, I can see that while it may indeed be theater, it sure isn't mere.

My family gathered in to watch the Clintons -- we even let the boys stay up late. I don't know what your impression of Hillary Clinton is, but in my lingering 1990s hangover I thought of her as a cross between Madame Nu and the Bride of Frankenstein.

Instead we got this bubbly lady with apple cheeks, smiling and buoyant and wearing a banana yellow pants suit. She was ease itself, not even shunning the issue of health care, her great failure, but instead bravely returning to the ramparts. That takes guts.

"She might become the first woman president,'' my wife told the boys. No arguments came to mind. And Bill Clinton was even more impressive. Smart, witty and memorable. "Strength and wisdom are not opposing values.'' What a great line, and the slyest shot at George Bush I've heard (most Democratic attacks have the subtly of a thrown brick). I'm sure the paladins were gnawing on their sofa cushions up in Kenilworth. But it jolted us wavering Dems like a fire bell in the night.

Sweetness

I shouldn't allude to my exchange with Lynn Sweet without elaborating. It was my fault. She had come home to the Mother Ship from our Washington office last week, and I could immediately tell she just wasn't brimming with her usual warmth vis-a-vis a certain longtime colleague.

"Whatsa matter Lynn,'' I called out at her, jollily as she strode by, "don't you love me anymore?''

She rounded on me, eyes ablaze. "How can you dismiss the convention as theater when you haven't studied the schedule?'' she said, or something similar -- I wasn't taking notes -- "Do you know all the relevant meetings? Have you done any analysis?''

Of course not. "Happy is he,'' the saying goes, "who didn't have to go to hell to see what the devil looks like.'' I tried to say something light and soothing, but she didn't buy it.

I felt crushed, as if, over tea with a beloved aunt, she had tossed a cup of jasmine in my face and bolted. I've been playing grasshopper to Lynn's ant for 17 years, and adore her: She's sharp and she knows everything and really cares about politics. Who else takes this stuff seriously enough to march into my office and upbraid me over my latest ethical or professional lapse? She was a great hostess when I was in Washington last year, introducing me to the National Press Club, where the drinks are cheap and well-poured, and slipping me into the White House so I could lay eyes on George and Laura Bush. I tell you, I lose more friends this way. I'm going to end up all by myself, tossing cards into a hat.

Pot shots

*The networks did the Democrats a favor by limiting their live coverage to an hour a night -- that way, people who tune in get the cream and nothing more. I watched C-Span earlier in the day when the convention opened to a half-empty hall. It was like watching public access cable. I half expected a bunch of second-graders to come out and sing, "How Much is That Doggy in the Window?''

*I hate to sound like Ann Coulter. But TV coverage of the audience at the Democratic convention reminded me of the bar scene in "Star Wars.'' Every time the cameras turned to the crowd they focused on an Eskimo or a Pacific Islander or a senior citizen wearing Bozo glasses and a floppy hat. The Democrats are the party of inclusion, so why couldn't TV include a few of us white guys in neckties, just for novelty's sake?

Parking lots, lots of parking

As someone with a taste for esoteric books, I snatched up a copy of the newly published Lots of Parking: Land Use in a Car Culture, written by a pair of University of Illinois professors, John A. Jakle and Keith A. Sculle.

Their basic thesis is hard to argue against -- that while the free and open road is celebrated in story and song and critiqued up and down, nobody bothers much about parking, even though it has reshaped our landscape as much, if not more, than highways.

"American geography has been totally reorganized around motor vehicles and the need to park those vehicles,'' said Jakle, whose previous books with Sculle include studies of gas stations, motels and fast-food restaurants -- subjects which, of course, led to parking.

"We realized that our emphasis was on objects and not paying sufficient attention to geographical space,'' he said.

I gathered my courage and told the professor that some people might view his chosen field as, well, somehow obscure.

"I guess it is an obscure topic,'' he said. "But it's also fundamental and essential in America today. It's something so common, we usually don't choose to think about it seriously. We don't see it, but it's everywhere.''

Sort of like politics.

 
 












News | Sports | Business | Entertainment | Lifestyles | Classifieds

Visit our online partners:
Daily Southtown      Pioneer Press      Suburban Chicago Newspapers      Post-Tribune
Star Newspapers      Jerusalem Post      Daily Telegraph

Copyright 2004, Digital Chicago Inc.