Before he went on stage, the camera swooped down on "American Idol"
contestant Adam Lambert as he stood beaming in the crowd. But as
usual, Lambert was more than just a face in the crowd on Tuesday
night, as he again wowed the judges and solidified his frontrunner
status.
It was Disco Week on "Idol," and true to the theme Lambert sang the
Bee Gees hit "If I Can't Have You," effortlessly hitting the high
notes and inspiring judge Paula Abdul to gush that his performance
made her feel his "pain." Abdul was not alone. All the judges said
they loved the performance, with alpha judge Simon Cowell
commending Lambert for surprising him by picking a Bee Gees
song.
"I would have put $10,000 you were going to do Donna Summer, but
that's what's so good about you, you did something we weren't
expecting," Cowell said.
Speaking of betting, it seems the smart money is on Lambert. Online
betting firm BookMaker.com, which usually confines itself to sports
gambling, said on Tuesday that the "Idol" title appears to be
Lambert's to lose, if he does not slip up.
At the other end of the spectrum, embattled singer Lil Rounds
continued to leave the judges unimpressed. She sang the Chaka Khan
hit "I'm Every Woman," and although her performance was energetic
and confident, judge Randy Jackson faulted her for a lack of vocal
control. Lil said that she had a good time with the song, which
only gave Cowell an opening to tear her down.
"I'm glad you had fun, because I think this is going to be the last
week we're ever going to see you," Cowell said.
Cowell had a similarly biting critique for Anoop Desai's version of
the Donna Summer song "Dim All the Lights."
"It was a horrible version of that song, and in my opinion,
genuinely that was your worst performance by a mile," Cowell
said.
With a completely different take, judge Kara DioGuardi told Desai
he has been at the top of his game the past couple of weeks, even
though the voters put him in the Bottom Three for each of the past
three weeks.
Allison Iraheta continued to hold her own with her version of "Hot
Stuff," another Donna Summer hit. Cowell called the slowed-down
rendition "brilliant" and Jackson said the 16-year-old Iraheta was
one of the best singers in the competition.
Matt Giraud, who was saved from elimination by the judges last
week, sang the appropriately-chosen Bee Gees song "Stayin' Alive,"
a disco-era hallmark. The judges gave him mostly positive reviews,
as they did for Danny Gokey's rendition of "September" by Earth,
Wind & Fire.
Judge Paula Abdul saved her best comment for contestant Kris Allen,
who sang yet another Donna Summer song, "She Works Hard for the
Money." Allen gave a new twist to what is a very feminine song,
bringing the band on stage with him and performing the tune with an
acoustic flavor.
"A lot of women are known to shop in the mens' department, but
there aren't many men that are willing to shop in the womens'
(department)," Abdul said. "I've got to tell you that you shopped
and you found a perfect fit."
Which contestants were a perfect fit for the audience on Tuesday
night? And which two will get the axe tomorrow night? Will the
disco ball finally come down on Lil Round's "Idol" dreams, or will
the audience ignore the judges' criticism of her and give the
Memphis mom another chance?
COPYRIGHT: (c) Reuters 2009. All rights reserved.
Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by
caching, framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without
the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters and the Reuters
sphere logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of the Reuters
group of companies around the world.