Loading...
Wells Fargo - Advocate Money Minute Static
|| Commentary ||
1 2 3 NEXT  Page 1 of 3

View From Washington: Straight WH Allies

COMMENTARY: Can advisers be fierce advocates on LGBT issues without being LGBT? White House policy chief Melody Barnes argued they could when asked about the lack of a senior LGBT official in Obama's inner circle.

MELODY BARNES WHITE HOUSE X390 (GETTY IMAGES) | ADVOCATE.COM
Senior White House adviser Melody Barnes was in the unenviable position Thursday of fielding questions from eight LGBT reporters and bloggers — a first-of-its-kind briefing 18 months into an administration whose commander in chief hasn’t given a single interview to an LGBT outlet nor taken a single question from one.

Yesterday I attempted to squeeze the news from the meeting (other than the fact that it happened), which involved no new policy announcements and was essentially a reiteration of things most people who have been following LGBT concerns closely probably already know.

But one issue that surfaced several different ways in questions asked by Chris Geidner of Metro Weekly, Pam Spaulding of Pam’s House Blend, and Joe Sudbay of AmericaBlog was why there isn’t a high-level LGBT adviser somewhere in Obama’s inner circle — either someone who is LGBT and has direct access to the president or someone who has direct access and is specifically responsible for advocating on behalf of LGBT people.

Barnes, who is as knowledgeable about LGBT policy as any one of us could hope and who has worked on gay issues for over a decade (including eight years in Sen. Ted Kennedy’s office) and who — I would hazard to guess — is probably the strongest advocate for LGBT causes in Obama’s cohort of senior advisers, gave a very thoughtful answer. It’s an answer that I don’t entirely agree with but that's worthy of debate, and so, at the risk of boring readers, I am going to run a good chunk of her answer before playing devil’s advocate.

Melody Barnes: “I think that there are a number of very senior members of this administration, whether it be Rahm [Emanuel] or Valerie [Jarrett] or me or Jim [Messina] that are not gay or lesbian for whom these issues are important and [who] have conversations and provide advice to the president on these issues. And I think that it is helpful and important to have people — and before you react to this I want to follow this up — who are not gay or lesbian or transgender who care about these issues and are advocating for them in the White House.

“It was Rahm who was pushing the hospital visitation piece. The chief of staff to the president went to the Oval Office and said, ‘I think that this is something important that we need to do.’
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Twitter. Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Facebook. 1 2 3 NEXT  Page 1 of 3
Reader Comments
  • Name: doug
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 10:52:26 PM
    Hometown: vb

    Comment:

    that's WOULDN'T have wasted 2 years (like Obama)......

  • Name: doug
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 7:20:04 PM
    Hometown: vb

    Comment:

    because Hillary had 16 years experience dealing with Republicans and would have wasted 2 years watering things down to get them on her side- she would have known that was impossible and gone ahead and did what needed to be done. Plus- she extended benfits/rights and protections at State long beofre the Pres attempt anything on our behalf.

  • Name: maybair
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 4:05:47 PM
    Hometown: new york

    Comment:

    Why do you idiots believe Hilary would've done any better? She held the same positions as he did, and she would've also employed clintonians responsible for DADT, DOMA etc. I am disappointed with Obama, but I don't see how Hillary would've been better on LGBT rights.

  • Name: jon
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 2:43:48 PM
    Hometown: norfolk

    Comment:

    I hope Hillary leaves and runs against him in 12....always got a gay vibe off Rahm- maybe it's the Julliard/ballet background

  • Name: Greg
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 9:40:02 AM
    Hometown: Providence RI

    Comment:

    She defends Rahm Emanuel as the main champion of gay stuff. Although I guess I'm relieved to hear he's cussing up a fucking storm for us occasionally in the "fucking retarded" White House, it's already known that Rahm is fucking leaving later this year. (Apparently you need to cuss at No Drama Obama to really get his attention on anything.) Others she mentions may be leaving too, so their replacements could be significant. Obama just doesn't seem to care much about gay stuff, so it does seem it would help if there were a gay adviser - ideally one who cusses a lot - to get his attention once in awhile!

  • Name: Robert
    Date posted: 7/4/2010 3:36:18 AM
    Hometown: Boston, MA

    Comment:

    Well damn! Ainit it nice that the folks up in the big house is representin fo me! Glory! The promised land is come! Can this Administration be any more insulting!? What are we? A group of flower arrangers hired for the entertaiment of the White House! If they do not see that their belittleing behavior is not any different than that of the Republicans then they do not deserve my vote. If you want someone to represent Queer people in the White Houes, elect a Queer President! DO NOT SPEAK FOR ME! I CAN DO IT ON MY OWN!

  • Name: mike
    Date posted: 7/3/2010 5:57:46 PM
    Hometown: cincinnati

    Comment:

    No straight person could take the place of a gay person. There should be one cabinet position for a gay person. A straight person will only offer to include a gay such as for picnics, easter egg hunts, etc. Sweet! These are photo opportunities and nothing more. Gays need to be included in Mr. Inclusive's administration. Obama is just reminding us of our second class status.

  • Name: Craig
    Date posted: 7/3/2010 4:38:29 PM
    Hometown: W.C.

    Comment:

    Obama believes he is a gifted orator. He believes that he can quell dissatisfaction, push through any agenda. unite all opposition by giving a speech. After all that is how he was elected, isn't it? He had no track record, but man he could sure give a good speech. And, we all bought it. The guy is learning politics as he goes. And, I truly believe that the only reason that the above meeting was given is because re-election is just around the corner I personally have started to cringe every time he makes what should be a ten to fifteen minute speech and he goes on and on and on for an hour. Just, shut up and do something.

  • Name: doug
    Date posted: 7/3/2010 1:58:12 PM
    Hometown: vb

    Comment:

    I don't want to see any 'where would we be with McCain/Palin' posts- that's a childish argument- Barrack won off promises he made and has failed to deliver on- playing 'what if' isn't constructive.

  • Name: Mark
    Date posted: 7/3/2010 12:24:39 PM
    Hometown: Tesuque

    Comment:

    Hillary 2012



More Online Only
  • News Features Skin for the Win

    Editor Zack Rosen is the winner of a full scholarship to this month's NetRoots Nation summit in Vegas — and all he had to do to win was promise to take off his pants.

  • Books Maggie Griffin: Out of the Box

    The reality television star, boxed-wine aficionado, and new author opens up about drinking with Betty White, her “boyfriend” Bill O’Reilly, and why she supports gay rights.

  • Film Video Content Flag A Changeling for Love

    In I Am Love, her first film as a credited producer, Oscar-winner Tilda Swinton stars as a wealthy housewife blindsided by a passion that threatens to destroy her carefully cultivated existence.

  • Health and Treatments Living the Questions

    COMMENTARY: "What has Pride done for you?" Advocate contributor Tyler Helms reflects on gay pride and how it helped shape one of the biggest decisions of his life — to come out as HIV+.

  • DVDs Hot Sheet: Cruise, Shears, and Hate Crimes

    Tom Cruise, Jake Shears, the Indigo Girls, and a touching documentary about a 16-year-old boy (pictured) who is brutally attacked for being gay make up this week in film, music, and books.

  • Sports The Shirtless Men of the World Cup

    World Cup fever is sweeping the States, and unlike in most other sports, when a game's done, the men — and even some of the female fans — take off their clothes.

  • Film Joan Rivers Better Work

    With a new documentary in theaters and a summer of stand-up dates, septuagenarian comic Joan Rivers explains why AIDS jokes are funny and why gay celebrities should only come out for publicity.

  • Commentary Interpreting Families

    COMMENTARY: U.S. Secretary of Labor Hilda Solis says changes to the Family and Medical Leave Act allowing family leave to anyone who assumes the role of caring for a child aren't just niceties for LGBT families — they're necessities.

  • Music Angelo Garcia: "I Came Out Before Ricky"

    Angelo Garcia is looking to shed the "other gay member of Menudo" label with the release of his new pop album. He just wants to make sure the media knows he's not riding Ricky Martin's coattails.

  • Health and Treatments The New 60: I Am Who I Am

    Advocate columnist Robert Levithan says he remembers being OK with civil unions because he was used to accepting less. Now, he says, with the help of his nephew, he insists on equal rights.

  • Television Bringing Gay Marriage to N.Y., Dina-Style

    A lot of reality stars say they support gay rights, but former Housewife Dina Manzo is putting her money where her mouth is — and has a few choice words for newly "bi" former cast mate Danielle Staub in the process.

  • Features Girls Who Say They Like Girls

    Whether they're doing it for a PSA (Anna Paquin) or on the eve of their album release date (Christina Aguilera), few things seems to make news like a lady announcing she's dallied with ladies.

  • Film The Kids Are All Right Premieres

    Julianne Moore, Mark Ruffalo, and Jane Lynch were just a few of the stars who attended the premiere of Lisa Cholodenko's highly anticipated new film, The Kids Are All Right.

  • Television On With the Cho 

    Drop Dead Diva star Margaret Cho talks distributing The Advocate in the South, cruising men at Home Depot, and remaking "Cold Hearted"with Paula Abdul.

 
1039 cover x135 | ADVOCATE.COM