|| Commentary ||
Share EMAIL PRINT POST COMMENT(40)
 
1 2 3 NEXT  Page 1 of 3

A Case for Outing on All Levels

COMMENTARY: Seen a local antigay politician having a beer at your favorite gay bar? You best speak up about it.

A CASE FOR OUTING ON ALL LEVELS X390 (SCOTT MCPHERSON) | ADVOCATE.COM

When antigay California state senator Roy Ashburn came out in March—only after he was busted for drunk driving following a night out at a Sacramento gay bar—he became the latest chapter of a story too many of us are sick of reading.

Ashburn, a 56-year-old Republican from Bakersfield, supported Proposition 8 and voted against gay rights initiatives. He continues to stand by his homophobic record, as do his hypocritical political compatriots—people like Idaho’s former U.S. senator Larry “Wide Stance” Craig.

What was truly surprising in the scandal, however, was the fact that so many people in Sacramento knew Ashburn was gay but chose not to speak out about it. This wasn’t a guy who was soliciting sex in airport restroom stalls; he was out in public, boozing in the gay bars and nightclubs. He was known by many prominent individuals and average folks to be gay.

After Ashburn’s arrest and awkward coming-out, many gay Sacramento residents told media outlets they knew about the secret life of this divorced politician and father of four. An eviscerating post about Ashburn on the blog JoeMyGod, titled “Collusion: People Knew Roy Ashburn Was Gay and They Said Nothing,” raised an important question: When the mainstream media and gay leaders fail to expose hypocrisy, is it time for an army of LGBT bloggers on the local level in every corner of the country to speak truth to power by holding the Roy Ashburns of their communities accountable?

In the context of the evolving national discussion on outing the Ashburn cover-up was quite startling. While Ashburn was hanging out at Sacramento gay bars, like Faces and Badlands, Kirby Dick’s documentary film Outrage had just been released on DVD after opening in theaters and running on HBO throughout 2009. The film (in which I was among those interviewed about the many stories I’ve reported on as a journalist exposing closeted public figures) makes a compelling case for outing antigay politicians—and explains how outing can be both responsible and relevant journalism. As politically sophisticated as California is, one would think many people surely got that message long before Outrage, particularly in the state’s robust LGBT activist community. So why wasn’t Roy Ashburn outed long ago?

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Twitter. Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Facebook. 1 2 3 NEXT  Page 1 of 3
Share EMAIL PRINT POST COMMENT(40)
 
Reader Comments
  • Name: Erick Myers
    Date posted: 7/11/2010 10:39:08 AM
    Hometown: Burssels, Belgium

    Comment:

    A politicians' financial interests, membership in organizations and aspects of their lifestyle that are relevant to causes, issues and laws they choose to support should be disclosed to the voters they represent. To do otherwise is simply dishonest.

  • Name: Dick Schmidt
    Date posted: 7/7/2010 5:02:43 AM
    Hometown: Honolulu

    Comment:

    Mike, we need some outing help. Closeted lesbian governor Linda Lingle today vetoed a civil unions bill in Hawaii. Everyone "knows" she's a lesbian, most people think her senior political advisor Linda Smith is her lover, but no one talks about it probably because we were hoping she'd do the right thing and either sign the bill (HB444) or at least do nothing and let it become law, and also I don't know anyone with proof that she is what it seems obvious she is. She has serious national Republican ambitions.

  • Name: Bruce Thompson
    Date posted: 7/5/2010 11:58:35 AM
    Hometown: Riverside, CA

    Comment:

    Dominick you seem to be a mature, healthy gay man. BRAVO to you and those who have been a part of your life.

  • Name: Bruce Thompson
    Date posted: 7/5/2010 10:28:29 AM
    Hometown: Riverside, CA

    Comment:

    Charles your comments were thoughtful and right on! BUT WE ALL MUST BE MINDFUL, not necessarily you, that he is not a private citizen with no significant influence on other people's lives, GAYS/MSM, and others, but hurtful, internalized homophobia diminish and sometimes KILLS the lives of others! Bruce Thompson, licensed mental health practitioner.

  • Name: P.
    Date posted: 7/2/2010 11:31:59 AM
    Hometown: Chicago

    Comment:

    These kind of tactics only serve to boost the morale of some gays with nothing else to appreciate their own lives on. It goes absolutely nowhere with the general public, who will still maintain their beliefs. Therefore, it is politically pointless. There's bigger fish to fry, folks... c'mon.

  • Name: allison
    Date posted: 7/2/2010 12:12:08 AM
    Hometown: TX

    Comment:

    I struggle with this, since i know what it feels like to be publicly outed. It sucks! But where is the line, should you expose the person because they are hindering your way of life by voting against your rights or do you say nothing because you know what its like to be prematurely ripped from your denial?

  • Name: Michelle
    Date posted: 7/2/2010 12:03:59 AM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    Phyllis i think the point is not whether he is gay or bisexual its that he is denying being either one and voting against gay rights all the while he is roaming gay bar looking to hook up with men. Its hypocritical...

  • Name: phyllis
    Date posted: 6/29/2010 11:35:18 AM
    Hometown: Williams, AZ.

    Comment:

    What I don't understand is why people say passing as straight instead of bisexual. This senator had four kids- this tells me he at least got it up for a women at four different times! Maybe more, maybe he is attracted to women as well as men. It's annoying to see people in the LGBT community forget about the b, as if we don't exist. To quote Kinsey people aren't just divided into sheeps and goats. It's their choice to come out as whatever and whenever they want to.

  • Name: Charles
    Date posted: 6/18/2010 5:58:55 PM
    Hometown: Austin, TX

    Comment:

    I think that we are dealing with a similar problem that was also felt in other communities facing similar difficulties. Namely, that some of us can pass for straight... and labels are not as "black and white" as we may like them to be. I don't know that because a man likes to get freaky with other men that makes him automatically gay. Maybe all that other man means to him is a warm place to put his penis. Maybe we need to define what it is to be gay more concisely. Maybe we should define it as being those who are out and proud with who they are and who choose to have a RELATIONSHIP with a member of the same sex. Maybe this would make pursuing marriage worthwhile. And then when we find those politicians, celebrities, or the like who are on the DL we can confront that behavior for whatever it happens to be. But to give them the honorary title of gay that we have fought so hard for seems to be an injustice and to me somehow makes our label and the outing process seem like a punishment.

  • Name: Dominick
    Date posted: 6/18/2010 12:30:54 AM
    Hometown: Charlotte

    Comment:

    I'm shocked and saddened by some of the comments. Of course, politicians should be outed. So should anyone known to be married to a women. (Being gay, then lying to a woman, causing her to fall in love, and then marrying her sd be crime. Sd be test beforehand.) We all knew we were gay when we had puberty. None of us have ever felt sexual attraction to a woman. Our bodies told us who we are. The 'choice' is whether to go along with the default assumption that everyone is straight. More: to be in the closet is to give proof that you regard being gay as inferior or disgusting or wrong in some way. To collude in some fellow gay guys lie is to support that falsehood. It's beyond the individual. The point is that being gay is fine and how we are meant to be. You can't reconcile that with pretending to be straight, which includes being coy to allow others to assume you are. The great news is that the youngsters are coming out at earlier and earlier ages en masse.

 PREVIOUS 1 2 3 4 NEXT  


More Online Only
  • News The New 60

    Advocate columnist Robert Levithan attends the 25th anniversary reading of Larry Kramer’s The Normal Heart and is reminded of the costs of internalized prejudice and self-hatred.

  • News A Seat at the Table

    Courage Campaign president Rick Jacobs says there is a time for pushing leaders to act and a time for mobilizing support for action ... and elections are a time for the latter.

  • Washington D C View From Washington

    A series of strange and unfortunate circumstances culminated in two notable LGBT advancements this week, delivered by President Barack Obama and Defense secretary Robert Gates.

  • Art Slideshow Flag Artist Spotlight: Scott G. Brooks

    Scott G. Brooks takes social, psychological, and political issues and injects them with a dark sense of humor in the distorted reality of his artwork.

  • DVDs The Hot Sheet

    BearCity delivers for fur lovers, the controversial Ticked-Off Trannies With Knives gets a theatrical release, while Glee's Mark Salling goes solo, Bette Davis plays twins, and sexy Argentinian rivals crawl in bed.

  • News Ending the Culture of Hate

    Teen suicide, hate violence in the street. New York City Anti-Violence Project's executive director Sharon Stapel wonders: Can we end the culture of hate?

  • Commentary My First 20 Dates

    Twenty dates into his 30-date journey, Kevin Richberg looks back on what he's learned, what he's liked, and why he doesn't worry about a Men's Fitness model not liking him.

  • Theater Backstage: Women on the Verge

    In his latest column, Broadway performer John Carroll nearly dies when Patti LuPone admits to reading his "blog" and shares his scary All About Eve fantasy.

  • Theater Seat Filler

    The Advocate’s man on the New York theater scene ushers in a bloody bloody good season with T.R. Knight, Cherry Jones, Charles Busch, Anthony Rapp, and the return migration of Matthew Bourne’s shirtless gay swans.

  • Commentary Duane: Seen It All Before

    New York State senator Thomas Duane says Obama's appeal of the anti-DOMA ruling is just the latest example of a politician claiming to be a friend of LGBTs while at the same time insisting his hands are tied.

  • DVDs The Hot Sheet

    Helen Mirren packs heat, Glee tackles Rocky Horror, Celebration's Take Me Out spotlights teammates in towels, and Norman Bates is back.

  • News Video Content Flag “Oh, My God,” It’s Craigery 

    His “Surprise Party” sketch made more than 3.5 million YouTube fans laugh. Now Craigery Morgan tells The Advocate why he did it with his shirt off and why he hopes it inspires more young gay people to be themselves.

  • Commentary Naked Ambition: Under Pressure

    Lesbian porn director Jincey Lumpkin leaves her adventures in the adult entertainment industry behind this week to talk about her own brush with suicide and why LGBT teens just need to hang on.

  • Film Video Content Flag Trevor’s Life Goes On

    Brett Barsky, the straight, married father of two who 16 years ago played the title character in the landmark short film that inspired the Trevor Project, discusses the lasting impact of Trevor and offers advice for suicidal teens.

  • DVDs The Hot Sheet

    Josh Duhamel and Katherine Heigl seek the advice of some gay neighbors, a teenage John Lennon, the ’70s flick with several minutes of gay sex scenes, and a happy Dave Koz.

  • Theater On the Road With Laramie

    Advocate columnist Greg Pierotti finds that technical rehearsals for The Laramie Project: 10 Years Later are draining because the cast is so deeply connected to Matthew Shepard's story.

Facebook Activity