Latest News
spacer View All spacer
 
October 20, 2010
 
In-Depth: THQ's Bilson Talks Big AAA Goals For New Montreal Studio [5]
 
Study: Workers Trained On Video Games Perform Better [3]
 
GDC China Adds Angry Birds, Monaco Creators To Summits
spacer
Latest Features
spacer View All spacer
 
October 20, 2010
 
arrow The State of Social in Social Games [6]
 
arrow NPD: Behind the Numbers, September 2010 [3]
 
arrow Flying With Four Engines: Tim Schafer On Double Fine's New Mission [6]
spacer
Latest Jobs
spacer View All     Post a Job     RSS spacer
 
October 20, 2010
 
Sledgehammer Games / Activision
Senior Lighting Artist
 
Total Immersion Software,Inc.
Quality Assurance Tester for Mobile Applications
 
Trion Worlds
Director of Sales and Marketing, Europe
 
Total Immersion Software,Inc.
Front End Web Engineer
 
Foundation 9 - Double Helix Games
Sr. Tools Programmer
 
Foundation 9 - Double Helix Games
Senior Producer
spacer
Blogs

  Why School Wasn't Right For Me
by Tyler Glaiel on 10/17/10 04:34:00 pm   Expert Blogs   Featured Blogs
10 comments Share on Twitter Share on Facebook RSS
 
 
  Posted 10/17/10 04:34:00 pm
 

You might have heard, in my last blog post, that I've been working as a full time indie developer for over a month now. I wasn't cool enough to "quit my job to go indie", but I did the next best thing and dropped out of school to go indie. I usually enjoyed school too, so some people (my parents) were probably confused as to why I made the decision to leave (though are probably glad they don't have to pay tuition anymore). Anyway we need to start with my highschool experience to fully understand my perspective.

I went to a highschool in the western boondocks part of Massachusetts. Not quite the middle of nowhere, but not quite a bustling city either. I lived next to cows and corn though, on the edge of this town (i.e. a good 10 miles away from any of my friends). It basically meant I couldn't really have any social life outside of school before I had my drivers license (so I managed to pass the time by learning how to program games in flash. I'd known pretty much my whole life this was what I wanted to do). Hence, I joined the band (in my high school the band wasn't just "the weird band geeks", there were nearly 200 people in it since we had a really good music program); I joined the honor society; I got involved.

Academically, I was a good student. I was in AP classes and the honor society and related stuff. The important part about being an honor student in high school was knowing how to slack effectively, and everyone knew it. We had an honor student lounge that we could go to in our free time. They probably expected us to use it to study, but we played video games and watched movies and joked instead. Everyone had a great idea of the minimum amount of work you had to put into each class to get an A, so the effort saved could be put into subjects you cared about, or just having a good time. 

I never really learned that much directly from the classes. I would slack too much in the classes I didn't care about, and in the subjects I did I would usually learn on my own at a rate faster than the class could go (they had to stick me in calculus a year early so I wouldn't get bored. I still got bored), and had more time to slack as a result. By senior year, I was taking 3 band classes out of the 7 slots we had. We slacked there too. Much of the day was spent… hitting fruits and donuts with golf clubs, and watching youtube instead of playing instruments. It was pretty fun too and quite enjoyable nonetheless.

We were always taught that the point of highschool was to get into a good college, and the point of college was to get a job. College for me wasn't much different from high school, academically. I would teach myself the subjects I cared about, and slack on the ones I didn't, and spend the rest of the time socializing. So why didn't I think it was worth it then? Stuff changes a lot once you realize you're paying for something. We pay for things we can't acquire on our own. I can't make my own LCD screen, so I buy a TV. I cannot cook a pizza, so I buy one. I can't draw or animate for the life of me, so I pay an animator to do that instead.

I can educate myself. Not only that, but I had been doing so all throughout highschool. There were no programming or linear algebra classes in highschool, so I had been teaching myself those skills on my own. As a result I performed just fine without doing any work in the college classes corresponding to those subjects.

Does it mean I was smarter than the other students in the class? Absolutely not, I simply had a head start. I saw people who never touched a computer before take a programming class and emerge nearly an expert at those languages after a couple classes. Obviously the system was working for them, but for someone like myself it just didn't seem to be worth the cost to sit through classes of subjects I already knew, just to meet prerequisites for classes I would have found interesting.

C programming was a prerequisite for C++ programming. I only knew the basics of each going in (though C programming only covered the basics anyway), but C was very easy to pick up for someone who had been programming for as long as I had, so I passed the time by reading a book on C++. By the time that class came along, I had already taught myself 95% of what was covered in that class. Hence, I learned a LOT in college, though none of it came directly from the classes themselves. If I was able to skip the first few prerequisite classes, perhaps I would have started off on more even ground, but as it was I was perpetually about a year ahead in terms of personal skill from what the classes were teaching me.

That's not to say the classes weren't of value for the other students, anyone who went in without experience was brought up to speed very fast and learning at exactly the rate the classes were going. I watched a few talents emerge from people who had never realized they had it. For them, school is very much worth it.

The other focus of school then, was getting a job. We all were taught, by parents and teachers and counselors and the media that you need a college diploma to get a good job, or else you'll end up working in a McDonalds or a Wal Mart for the rest of your life. I can't really go get a diploma on my own, even if I could get an education on my own.

Though, in 2008 I began getting involved in the indie gaming scene, after I realized that the flash games I'd been making as a hobby for so long actually made me an indie developer. I went to GDC that year, began to realize that being an independent developer was actually becoming a viable career option. It was risky for sure. If I left right then and there to become indie, there'd be a huge risk if I couldn't handle it because then I'd be without a job AND without a diploma, and it also felt weird to question the "truth" of "high school -> college -> job".

Over the next 2 years, my game Closure began winning a few awards and attracting attention. I realized here that leaving school to be an indie developer wouldn't be as risky as I thought it was. I was getting pressured from family to stay in school, and other developers to leave, and random people on the streets would always feel the need to chime in with their suggestion if I mentioned I was thinking about it.

I even talked to a few professors at my school to see what they thought, expecting them to try and keep me in school so they could keep getting my tuition money, and to my surprise they mostly all told me that leaving wouldn't be a bad choice for my specific situation, under the premise of "you can always come back if you think you want a degree".

So I can educate myself, and I can probably succeed just fine without a diploma (crunching numbers I'd have to sell chicken scratch copies of my game to NOT break even), really left pretty much no reason for me to keep paying money to the school, so I left. My brother can make way better use of a college education than I can anyway, so my parents are probably glad that they can stop spending money on me and save it for him instead, even if they were averse to my decision initially.

This was really the first big decision in my life that was 100% my own decision, and, well, it feels kinda good to have control over my own life. Time will tell if I made the right choice, and frankly, I'm optimistic.

 
 
Comments

Andrew Calhoun
profile image
Nice article. School is not essential, but I think that a full, well rounded education is important, especially for those of us who are not self-starters. This does not sound like the case with you. Still, I believe it would not hurt you to go back at some point and finish as a point of pride. Either way, you have to make the decisions for yourself and if you can educate yourself and have the discipline to push forward, all the more power to you. In the end, if this is what you want, I say -go for it!-



Andrew Dobbs
profile image
You go to school to learn and eventually make money. If you have a different way to do that, then do it.



Nana Louise Nielsen
profile image
Great article with point well made.

My well meaning mum brought me up to believe the diploma was vital. I spent 3 years after highschool trying to get in to either of the two art/design universities in Denmark. Got in, but it was a constant struggle trying to get what I wanted out of the course opposed to what the teachers thought the point was.
In the end they failed me on my Master's project, mainly because I wanted to make games, not what they considered 'finer' design.
My mum was devastated. "Now you have to do another year to get your diploma."
I said no. That they didn't have more to teach me.
The way our industry in particular grows and evolves at such a speed, I think self-education can be much more viable and tailor-made better to fir exactly what you want to do.

You need to have the drive for it though.
btw nobody ever asked to see my diploma and after the first job they never asked about education only experience.



Chris K
profile image
I will acknowledge that self-education is better for the one subject you are passionate about. Sadly I think your decision is going to hurt you in the long term because of the less obvious things. You're in danger of becoming a shallow person who knows a lot about one thing and little about everything else. I think it is naive to think that school is just there to teach you to get a job.

For example, you are 100% correct: you can easily teach yourself a trade, like programming, on your own. But what about learning the things you wouldn't study on your own out of laziness? Philosophy, literature, general knowledge, trivia, science, math, biology, chemistry, other languages, politics: subject matter that you don't "like"? Unless you are the world's most self-disciplined person what you will become is a very ignorant and dull person who is an "expert" in only one thing and an idiot in all others. If you only want to be a good coder, you are right, you don't need a to go to school. If you want to be a well rounded, wise, interesting person... IMHO you might want to reconsider.

School provides other very valuable yet intangible things. What about friendships? Society? Community? Parties? Girls?



Tyler Glaiel
profile image
I DO teach myself business, math, science, philosophy, politics, and history on my own in small chunks. I can't stand literature though, but I'm practicing writing all the time (it's why I've been blogging. When I'm writing about a subject I actually care about, I tend to do well. If I have to write a 7 page essay on the metaphorical meaning of the color green in ClassicBookAboutDeath, not so much). I know how to play a few instruments, and a lot about music theory. I am an eagle scout, so I know all the first aid and survival skills and nature stuff they teach you there. I'm very well concerned about making sure I'm a well rounded person. I'd just much rather learn on my own terms.

I went to college for 2 years before deciding to leave too. Yes, a HUGE reason I decided to leave was because there'd be no way I could finish Closure while juggling schoolwork at the same time, and if I waited 2 more years to start working on it full time and another year to finish it, frankly people wouldn't care about it anymore.

I've heard all those arguments before too. As I said, everyone likes to chime in with their advice for my life when the subject comes up. I've thought about them all too. There are a few reasons for wanting to stay, though I don't think they are worth the cost of tuition.

And I most certainly don't think the 2 years I spent there were a waste of time either.



Ephriam Knight
profile image
"School provides other very valuable yet intangible things. What about friendships? Society? Community? Parties? Girls? "

I take it you are against the idea of homeschooling children?

The idea of getting a college education has been hammered into our children for decades now. It is no more true today than it was 50 years ago or a hundred years ago. We don't need a college education. We need training in a skill that will be useful to society and that will support our self and our family (if one so chooses to have one). If that training comes from college, so be it. If it comes through an alternative method, so be it.

There are many trades that do not require a college education only training in a trade program or apprenticeship. Yet the people who choose that path are just as interesting as anyone who went to college.

"Philosophy, literature, general knowledge, trivia, science, math, biology, chemistry, other languages, politics: subject matter that you don't "like"?"

Who says you have to learn any of that to be an effective member of society? No one. If you are not interested in something, there is no reason for you to force yourself to learn the subject. Does it broaden your mind? Possibly, but for a lot of people it just bores them.

I personally have problems with universities and their need to pad your degree with "general education" requirements that are not needed in the career path you want to go into.

I am a friend with a 19 year old who has been running a successful web design studio since he was 16. He has several national clients as well as local clients. I asked him recently if he planned to go to college and his response was that he did not need it. He knows what he wants to do and he does it well enough to earn a living at it. I have no doubts that he will succeed despite his lack of a college degree.



Patrick Coan
profile image
Sore subject for me. If I spent the time as a designer I spent in school, I may have a job right now. Instead I am mountains in debt, and my degree means very little to the people who would be hiring. Funny, because diligence is not the issue here. I feel like a suggestion that school is a good idea comes from others who have had to use that route and would wish the burden on someone because they justify it for themselves, or people who never went and aren't employed in their desired field. I don't need a school to educate me about ethics, philosophy, world issues, literature, etc. The desire to learn those things needs to be intrinsic and if it's not, I doubt it will be learned in any case.



James Hofmann
profile image
You aren't wrong, I think. I ended up finishing college, but wanted to quit for indie games in sophomore year myself, although I probably wasn't ready yet and my parents firmly pushed me the other way(with the biggest incentives being them willing to continue footing the bill, and no real fruition of my efforts yet). In high school I was too drained of energy to make a lot of progress towards any goals, so I didn't get the fast-track you've had. But in the end I still took the same step - going out and trying some bold things - and mostly failing at them, which is a great learning process. But it turns out that there are a zillion backup plans you can enact when you have the skills to do something like indie games, so it's not that scary if you're young and untied with debts or dependents.

The most shocking thing about entrepreneurship, really, is that the rulebook is so small. There are fees and paperwork, which are relatively easy to figure out, but the actual run-business-ship-product-make-money skills are an open thing and, much like the game-making process, not something you can study just from books or lectures. This is, I think, the main thing that makes it scary to go off the track of school->college->job and try to create something new. It actually doesn't matter at what point you leave that track - once you're off it, with the intention of staying off, you have to keep reevaluating your life and pursuits to move forward and stay focused on the business. School - and most jobs - are just a lot of waiting around, in comparison.



Nicholas Lovell
profile image
Congratulations on the bold choice. I hope that you enjoy doing interesting work and make time to focus on making money as well as making games.

Really good luck to you.



Bjorn Bednarek
profile image
I'm always in awe of people who take the plunge, any plunge, wholeheartedly. Well done and good luck to you. Betting on yourself is a brilliant thing and I hope it pays off. You sound like you're not doing it blindly and have really thought about it. I look forward to reading updates.

It's very easy to read success stories where you find out that very successful person X quit school, or left a high paying job or did something else risky that ultimately paid off. You rarely read about the other 100 people who did exactly the same thing that week, but ultimately ended up broke, or back at their old job,or failing in some way. I'm not saying you have a high chance of failure, I just always find myself thinking about the unknown people who tried to form their own band, business or other risky venture and failed. But maybe failing at something grand is much better than succeeding at being ordinary. In any case, I'm envious and once again wish you all the luck in the world.




none
 
Comment:
 


Submit Comment