I've always enjoyed Alexander McCall Smith in just about everyone of the books he's written, including the other series; but the crowning achievement is the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency books. McCall Smith has kept this series going through thirteen titles, and I'm surprised that no-one has written a review saying that this volume is not up to standard, as they did in previous Ladies' Detective" books.
In my less-than-humble opinion this book shows the same plotting skills as the previous dozen, plus I was constantly impressed by the quality of McCall Smith's writing. Some little turn of phrase begins to be something delightful, and this happens throughout the book. All the usual crew is here, doing the usual things, except for one of Mr. J.L.B Matekoni's apprentices - and it's not Charlie, for once, but the now ex-apprentice Fanwell who falls foul of the law.
One smart move by McCall Smith is to have a cast of characters who are so enjoyable we don't want anything bad to happen to them. We want those in trouble to come out on top, and we want Mme Ramotswe to uncover the truth and help out her clients, and in this book it's Mma Potokwane, the matron of the orphans farm, who is facing dismissal from her job. Add to this Phuti Radiphuti and his new bride, Grace Maskutsi are having a house built by a contractor who isn't quite following the rules. I raced through the book, hoping that all would come out well in the end.
One development that I thought McCall Smith would have trouble with was the arrival of Clovis Andersen, whose book The Principle of Private Detection has been the guide for the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency since day one. Yet somehow McCall Smith handles this brilliantly, with Andersen playing a largely supportive role and not taking over the entire book. And there's hours of hilarity awaiting you with a description of "Gaborone's Worst Lawyer" fouling up royally in court.
There is in fact plenty of humor in this book, more than usual but it doesn't intrude. My favorite moment was on page one, where Precious Ramotswe considers the effect of a spray that cured an uncomfortable conscience, and how it wouldn't work on the person who invented it, because he would have to consider the consequences of his action.
Even if you've never read a book in this series, this one will be understandable just like all the other ones, as McCall Smith ruminates on human nature. Nothing bad happens to the innocent, yet the personalities of the characters could lead to that. This isn't a Susie Sunshine story, even though it indulges feelings of comfort food.
So if you've ever had the slightest inclination to read one of the books in this series, just get any one of them and settle down for a comfortable few hours of reading. I can't believe that you'd come away with anything but a positive feel and the willingness to read every one of the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series.