Turkey Trots to
Water |
With 20/20 hindsight, the Iowa along with her sister
ship the
New Jersey should have been guarding the the approach to
Leyte Gulf tostop the Yamato. They were instead ordered
to protect Halsey's carriers in pursuit of Japan's
northern decoy force.
|
The Bulk of the United States Navy in
the Pacific, under the command of Chester A. Nimitz, operated under two different names,
and served under two different commanders who took alternating six-month tours "at
the wheel" of this vast force. When Admiral Raymond A. Spruance was in command, this
was the "Fifth Fleet." When Admiral William F. Halsey was in command, this was
the "Third Fleet." Other numbers were assigned to task forces and task groups,
always beginning with the number of the fleet. And thus the carrier arm of the Third Fleet
bore the designation Task Group 38, under the command of Admrial Marc A. Mitscher, and
consisted of the smaller task groups 38.1, 38.2, 38.3 and 38.4. Each of these Task Groups
had a few fast fleet carriers or fast light carriers. And, escorting each task group would
be a fast battleship or two.
While the slow pre-Washington Treaty battleships, capable of barely
22 knots on a good day, were assigned to the Seventh Fleet under Kinkaid, Halsey had at
his disposal the services of all the new "fast battleships" built after the
Washington Treaty. The North Carolinas and South Dakotas had a maximum speed
of 28 knots, while the fabulous Iowas could boast speeds in excess of 33 knots. Six
fast battleships were scattered among Task Groups 38.2, 38.3, and 38.4. Halsey himself was
aboard the New Jersey, the flagship of the Third Fleet.
These battleships were deployed to use their massive anti-aircraft
capabilities to protect the vulnerable carriers. And as such they served well. Although
there had not been a need to send battleships to engage an enemy surface force since
Guadalcanal, plans were made nonetheless to create a special unit consisting of all of the
Fast Battleships. This unit, bearing the name Task Force 34, would be under the command of
Vice Admiral Willis A. "Ching" Lee the very man who had lead the South
Dakota and Washington into their successful engagement with the Kirishima off
Guadalcanal back in 1942.
Messages had been sent by Halsey in Third Fleet and overheard by
Kinkaid in Seventh Fleet regarding the creation of Task Force 34. Kinkaid had assumed that
these messages indicated that Task Force 34 had been assembled, and was guarding the San
Bernardino Straight to the north of the island of Samar. So when Third Fleet radioed
Nimitz that it was "proceeding north with three groups", Halsey intended the
wording to indicate that he was taking everthing. Kinkaid, in Seventh Fleet, assumed that
"three groups" meant the three carrier groups, less the battleships of Task
Force 34, which he assumed were on station in San Bernardino straight. At a conference at
4:00 AM, Kinkaid asked "What are we forgetting?" and a staff officer recommended
that they actually confirm that Task Force 34 had actually been formed and that it was
indeed patrolling San Bernardino Straight. But the message was delayed for several hours,
due to the complexity of the command structure of the two separate fleets. Halsey did not
receive the message until three hours later - his first indication that something was
amiss.
As Kurita came crashing down on Ziggy Sprague's Taffy 3, Kinkaid was
sending frantic messages seeking help for the disaster that he was sure was about to
befall him. The first message stated "Urgently need fast BBs Leyte Gulf at once"
(BB was the naval abbreviation for "battleship.") At 9:00 was another
message, "Our CVEs being attacked by 4BBs, 8 cruisers plus others. Request (Admiral)
Lee cover Leyte at top speed. Request fast carriers make immediate strike." Halsey
returned messages stating the position of his forces, to show Kinkaid that his assistance
was impossible due to his position so far to the North. In utter desperation, Kinkaid sent
in the clear (uncoded) a message "Where is Lee? Send Lee!" Halsey was at this
time quite concerned, and as he was about to respond, he received another message. This
one was not from Kinkaid, it was from his commanding officer, Admiral Chester Nimitz in
Hawaii.
This message was not sent in the clear, it was encrypted. And as an
encrypted message, it had nonsense phrases selected from a codebook appended to the
beginning and end of the message set apart by a pair of repeated characters, in an attempt
to throw off any enemy deciphering of the message. For example, if a commander wished to
send a message to instruct his forces to attack the enemy at dawn, he would send something
like "RAIN MAKES MUD PUDDLES QQ ATTACK THE ENEMY AT DAWN LL PUPPY DOG TAILS". In
the course of naval transmissions, the enlisted men responsible for receiving these
messages would customarily clip the padding before delivering the message to the intended
recipient. When Nimitz grew confused about the situation off Samar, he requested that
Halsey be given a gentle nudge, to ask what the location was of Admiral Lee and his fast
battleships.
The message sent by Admrial Nimitz and received aboard the New
Jersey was "TURKEY TROTS TO WATER GG WHERE IS RPT (repeat) WHERE IS TASK FORCE THIRTY
FOUR RR THE WORLD WONDERS". When the message was delivered to Halsey, the padding
"Turkey trots to water" had fortunately been removed, but the signalman
recording the message failed to remove "the world wonders" from the end of the
message. Halsey read the message as a stinging slap from his friend and advocate, and with
great emotion threw his cap to the deck. And then, reluctantly, he ordered his battleships
to proceed South in an attempt to respond to Nimitz and to save Kinkaid. Unfortunately,
due to his northern position, he would arrive off Leyte a day after the Japanese had left.
Had Halsey stayed on station off San Bernardino Straight, he would have had his massive
surface battle. Had he continued on to the north, a different yet still massive surface
battle would have resulted. But, instead, his fleet of fast battleships sailed
ineffectually between the two engagements, unable to participate in either.
And so, an era came to a close. The battleship would never again
fire her guns at an enemy ship. And yet, even as the age of the battleship ended
fully eclipsed by the power of the Aircraft Carrier the battleship had lived up to
her potential. True, the massed air attacks from a dozen carriers had sunk the Musashi.
But they had not sunk the other four battleships they steamed resolutely on. Only
Kuritas disengagement at the last minute saved the day for the Americans. As for
Ozawas decoy force, it was the four carriers that were quickly sunk the
battleships Ise and Hyuga did not succumb to air attacks. It was the
battleship that Halsey had chosen as the instrument of the total destruction of
Ozawas force much as Kinkaid had used his much older battleships to totally
smash Nishimura.
But these facts were lost in the wash. The carrier would be the new
queen of the seas, for within a year, the war would be over. The mighty Yamato
would go down much as her sister the Musashi had done receiving concentrated
attacks directed solely against her from the bulk of the Pacific Fleet. The other Japanese
battleships, lacking sufficient fuel to put to sea, were picked off by American aircraft
while in port or under repair.
The Nagato, though badly mauled by attacking aircraft, would
be the sole Japanese battleship to survive the war. She would come within sight of
American battleships at last, but not as an adversary, nor as a friend, but simply as a
fellow victim of the atomic bomb tests conducted at Bikini. Joined by her distant cousins
the American battleships Arkansas, New York, Nevada and Pennsylvania,
the Nagato would be sunk at Bikini in July 1946 near the Arkansas and the
cruiser Prinz Eugen (companion of the Bismarck on her fatal voyage). Incredibly,
the New York, Nevada, and Pennsylvania would survive the blasts of
two atomic bombs, proving just how tough battleships - even old ones - could be, when
faced with the newest and most powerful of weapons. But in the end, these three
battleships would not live too long to enjoy their victory. All three of the veteran
battleships that survived Bikini were ultimately sunk as target ships in 1948.
Authors Note:
Many works contributed to the writing of this article and provided
different aspects of the battle. But for a full and complete telling of the story, there
is perhaps no better work than The Battle of Leyte Gulf by Thomas J. Cutler, a 379
page paperback by Pocket Books, ISBN 0-671-53670-2.
(Follow the links to each phase of the battle.)