Pravda.RU CNN Says Focus on Civilian Casualties Would Be "Perverse"

Pravda.RU:Main:More in detail

19:50 2001-11-02
CNN SAYS FOCUS ON CIVILIAN CASUALTIES WOULD BE "PERVERSE"
According to the Washington Post (10/31/01), CNN Chair Walter Isaacson "has ordered his staff to balance images of civilian devastation in Afghan cities with reminders that the Taliban harbors murderous terrorists, saying it 'seems perverse to focus too much on the casualties or hardship in Afghanistan.'"
Post reporter Howard Kurtz quotes a memo from Isaacson to CNN's international correspondents: "As we get good reports from Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, we must redouble our efforts to make sure we do not seem to be simply reporting from their vantage or perspective. We must talk about how the Taliban are using civilian shields and how the Taliban have harbored the terrorists responsible for killing close to 5,000 innocent people."
The memo went on to admonish reporters covering civilian deaths not to "forget it is that country's leaders who are responsible for the situation Afghanistan is now in," suggesting that journalists should lay responsibility for civilian casualties at the Taliban's door, not the U.S. military's.
Kurtz also quotes a follow-up memo from Rick Davis, CNN's head of standards and practices, that suggested sample language for news anchors:
" 'We must keep in mind, after seeing reports like this from Taliban-controlled areas, that these U.S. military actions are in response to a terrorist attack that killed close to 5,000 innocent people in the U.S.' or, 'We must keep in mind, after seeing reports like this, that the Taliban regime in Afghanistan continues to harbor terrorists who have praised the September 11 attacks that killed close to 5,000 innocent people in the U.S.,' or 'The Pentagon has repeatedly stressed that it is trying to minimize civilian casualties in Afghanistan, even as the Taliban regime continues to harbor terrorists who are connected to the September 11 attacks that claimed thousands of innocent lives in the U.S.' "
Davis stated that "even though it may start sounding rote, it is important that we make this point each time."
The New York Times reported (11/1/01) that these policies are already being implemented at CNN, with other networks following a similar, though perhaps not as formalized, strategy. "In the United States," the Times noted, "television images of Afghan bombing victims are fleeting, cushioned between anchors or American officials explaining that such sights are only one side of the story." In other countries, however, "images of wounded Afghan children curled in hospital beds or women rocking in despair over a baby's corpse" are "more frequent and lingering."
When CNN correspondent Nic Robertson reported yesterday from the site of a bombed medical facility in Kandahar, the Times reported that U.S. anchors "added disclaimers aimed at reassuring American viewers that the network was not siding with the enemy." CNN International, however, did not add any such disclaimers.
During its U.S broadcasts, CNN "quickly switched to the rubble of the World Trade Center" after showing images of the damage in Kandahar, and the anchor "reminded viewers of the deaths of as many as 5,000 people whose 'biggest crime was going to work and getting there on time.'"
If anything in this story is "perverse," it's that one of the world's most powerful news outlets has instructed its journalists not to report Afghan civilian casualties without attempting to justify those deaths. "I want to make sure we're not used as a propaganda platform," Isaacson told the Washington Post. But his memo essentially mandates that pro-U.S. propaganda be included in the news.

Visit http://www.fair.org/activism/cnn-casualties.html

you may discuss the article in our forum
Send it to a friend!

RIA 'Novosti'
U.S. Full Coverage
CNN/AllPolitics
Washington Post
Drudge Report

Pravda.RU:Main

21:36
COLLATERAL DAMAGE VII AC-130S BLAST CIVILIANS IN KANDAHAR
Eye witnesses inform western journalists about AC-130 Spectre aircraft deliberately strafing civilian targets in Kandahar. More details...

21:00
ANDREY LUBENKSY: LAND CODE VOTING RESULTS IN UKRAINIAN PARLIAMENT WERE FALSIFIED?
The commotion pertaining to the Land code, passed by the Ukrainian parliament is still going on. Some people say the bolsheviks motto Land to the peasants! has been implemented, others call this news the land counter-revolution and warn that the best land in the world will soon find themselves in oligarchs and bandits hands More details...

20:44
US LOSSES IN AFGHANISTAN: FROM 70 TO 100 PEOPLE
According to Western news agencies, the Qatar television network al-Jazeera, which has lately become almost the only source of information about Afghan developments, aired today an interview with Mr. Moulvi Rahmatallah Kakazada, the Talibans consul to Karachi. More details...

19:50
CNN SAYS FOCUS ON CIVILIAN CASUALTIES WOULD BE "PERVERSE"
According to the Washington Post (10/31/01), CNN Chair Walter Isaacson "has ordered his staff to balance images of civilian devastation in Afghan cities with reminders that the Taliban harbors murderous terrorists, saying it 'seems perverse to focus too much on the casualties or hardship in Afghanistan.'" More details...

19:15
PRAVDA.RU APPRECIATES CNN PRESS OFFICES WATCHFULNESS AND APOLOGIZES TO ITS READERS
CNN refutes the allegations that can be found in the article by Irina Malenko of October 26th, 2001 titled ASSOCIATION OF JOURNALISTS OF PALESTINE BLAMES CNN. More details...

18:43
RUSSIA AND WTO: ONLY THE STRONGEST WILL SURVIVE
The debates over Russias joining the World Trade Organization remain unabated. The near the joining date is coming, the more heated the debates become. The question to join or not to join became no longer relevant after President Vladimir Putins speech made at the guest session of the Davos economic forum held recently here in Moscow. More details...

18:25
DMITRY LITVINOVICH: THE COLOMBIAN DEATH SQUADS
The civil war in Colombia has been going on for over 30 years. Thousands of people died during the contradiction between the rebels and rightist armed groups. The Colombian army, by the way, has been actively supporting the latter More details...

16:38
THE KURSK SUBMARINE EXAMINED FROM WITHIN
The chairman of the governmental commission for investigating the reasons of the Kursk submarine crash, vice premier of the Russian government Ilya Klebanov did not exclude that the final reasons of the tragedy would be determined in two months More details...

16:08
ANOTHER POGROM IN MOSCOW PASSES OFF UNNOTICED
Yesterday, the mass media reported on a new pogrom in Moscow, this time in Moscows northwest, in the Tushino district. Local residents living on the Bolshaya Naberezhnaya Street relentlessly telephoned the police telling of a mass battle going on, in which about 100 people were taking part. More details...

16:02
BIN LADEN MET CIA IN AMERICAN HOSPITAL
Osama Bin Laden met a CIA agent in an American hospital in Dubai last July, according to the French daily Le Figaro. More details...

15:22
DMIRY LITVINOVICH: BUSINESS IN UKRAINE. OR VARYAGS LAST TRIP
How pitiful it is to take leave of the USSRs former grandeur. The country where we were born has disappeared from geographical maps, and all we have now is to complain about unwise politicians. More details...

15:20
SERGEY BORISOV: AMERICAN PROFESSORS SCOLD THE USA
A lot of American people fear that the US will lose a part of its democratic liberties during the struggle with terrorism. Someone is afraid lest the well-known freedom of speech should suffer, there are already certain trends of that More details...

13:50
THERE IS SOMETHING AMISS IN RUSSIAN CAPITAL. WITH BUILDING
Moscow confidently presses St Petersburg from the not very flattering place of Russian criminal capital. This week was marked with series of bloody crimes in the city: from the pogrom Tsaritshino market on October 30, to todays murder of deputy prefect of Northwest circuit. More details...

12:30
GOLOVLEVS CASE: COURT WILL CLEAR UP THE SITUATION
Oops! as our friends over the ocean say. State Duma deputy from Union of Right Forces faction, deprived of deputy immunity, brings an action against the State Duma. More details...

12:00
JOSEPH SOBRAN: PATRIOTISM OR NATIONALISM?
This is a season of patriotism, but also of something that is easily mistaken for patriotism; namely, nationalism. The difference is vital. G.K. Chesterton once observed that Rudyard Kipling, the great poet of British imperialism, suffered from a "lack of patriotism." More details...

11:20
ELECTION CAMPAIGN IN YAKUTIA: OUR LAST AND DECISIVE BATTLE. DO TODAYS AUTHORITIES PREPARE THE USSRS FATE FOR RUSSIA?
Pre-election process in Yakutia is at its height. Everything is involved: local election commission, Central Election Commission, Supreme Court of Yakutia, Russian Public Prosecutor Generals Office. Now it is turn of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. Though, thing are right where they started. More details...

10:00
JUSTIN RAIMONDO: ATTACK OF THE MCCAINIACS MAD BOMBER MCCAIN: WILL HE EVER SHUT UP?
War is hell and, thanks to Senator John McCain, it has just gotten a little more hellish. Writing in the Wall Street Journal, this angry embittered man has launched an effort to undermine the war effort, one that will no doubt be far more effective than the Lilliputian efforts of peaceniks. "War," he intones, "is a miserable business." Let us "shed a tear," he opines, "and then get on with the business of killing our enemies as quickly as we can, and as ruthlessly as we must." More details...

21:40
NATO WAR CRIMES IN KOSOVO THE EVIDENCE
20,000 explosive devices from unexploded NATO cluster bombs were scattered over Kosovo. Criticism is raised that cluster bombs kill more civilians in Kosovo than anti-personnel mines. More details...

21:14
THE SLAUGHTER IN TSARITSINO THE PROVOCATION OF THE SPECIAL SERVICES?
There are new comments coming about the events, which took place October 30 in the area of Moscows Tsaritsino underground station. We would like to remind you in short of what actually happened. A group of young men, about 500 of them, made a slaughter on the market place close to the underground station More details...

20:50
SIR MICHAEL HOWARD: MISTAKE TO DECLARE THIS A 'WAR'
When in the immediate aftermath of the attack on the World Trade Center the American Secretary of State Colin Powell declared that America was 'at war', he made a very natural but a terrible and irrevocable error. Leaders of the Administration have been trying to put it right ever since. More details...

19:57
ALEXANDER GOROBETS: MILITARY GAMES TO SAVE UKRAINIAN PRESIDENTS IMAGE
Cape of Opuk in the Crimea, which became known after the crash of the Russian Tu-154 passenger airliner, is now a place to gather a lot of military men today. This time there are both Russian and Ukrainian military men there. General Kuzmuk, the former Defense Minister of Ukraine, is absent More details...

19:50
WHAT IS SHEVARDNADZE TO DO?
The political crisis, which the Republic of Georgias President Eduard Shevardnadze so hoped to avert, has broken out after all. At todays extraordinary parliamentary session, Mr. Shevardnadze has announced the Georgian governments resignation. More details...

19:07
DMITRI LITVINOVICH: STATE MONOPOLY ON VODKA RETURNS TO RUSSIA
The epoch of the primary accumulation of capital has long been left behind in Russia. Todays businessmen are different from those of hot money hunters of the early 1990s. Present-day businessmen do care about their image. The state also tries to catch up with business and wants to show the West a beautiful glossy wrapping in the form of assurances of business being liberalized and corruption being fought. More details...

18:54
JOSEPH SOBRAN: PATRIOTISM OR NATIONALISM?
This is a season of patriotism, but also of something that is easily mistaken for patriotism; namely, nationalism. More details...

18:05
THE STATE DUMA VOTED: TO WITHDRAW IMMUNITY FROM DEPUTY VLADIMIR GOLOVLEV
The Russian Federation State Duma (the parliament) voted to withdraw the deputy immunity from the Union of Rightist Forces faction member, deputy chairman of the parliamentary committee for budget and revenues, Vladimir Golovlev More details...

17:03
HOW TO EARN TWO MILLION
There is a very simple way to earn 2 million: to seize a childrens hospital, take the personnel and visitors hostages, require ransom, receive it, and then leave. Does it seem impossible? Anything is possible in Russia. Especially when there is a large-scale conspiracy in which law-enforcement officers participate More details...

17:00
COMMUNISTS WERE DEVELOPING AFGHANISTAN
Opposition General Homayun Baha declares that if the Soviet Union did not conquer Afghanistan because it was not interested, and claims that the Communists were developing the country well before the Mujaheddin began the process which culminated in the Taleban. More details...

16:30
200,000 JOBS LOST IN AVIATION INDUSTRY
The aftermath of September 11th has been dramatic for the aviation industry, with an estimated 200,000 losses. More details...

16:29
THE TREE OF FREEDOM HAS FADED FOREVER
Mark Twain once said: The citizen who sees his societys democratic clothes being worn out and does not cry out is not a patriot but a traitor. America now seems to be ready to sacrifice its liberal values for the sake of the "victory" over terrorism. More details...

15:51
SIGNS OF DISCONTENT IN US POPULATION
Although the Unites States administration continues to enjoy massive support, there are clear signs that preoccupation and discontent are beginning to unsettle the people of the USA. More details...

Pravda.RU:Best articles on this week:Main

2001.10.31
BEAR CURED OF ALCOHOLISM

2001.10.31
ALEXEI BOGOMOLOV: OSAMA BIN LADEN CONTACTED CIA SHORTLY BEFORE TERRORIST ATTACKS

2001.10.26
PETR SEDOV: AMERICANPHOBIA OF MYTRIX ON RUSSIAN INTERNET

2001.11.01
THE TREE OF FREEDOM HAS FADED FOREVER

2001.10.30
AFGHANISTAN: HEATING UP!

2001.10.26
CENTRAL RUSSIAN TV CHANNEL COMPARES USA WITH HITLER GERMANY

2001.10.31
DMITRY LITVINOVICH: THE TALIBAN AND BIN LADEN ARE ONLY THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG

2001.10.31
RYAN MCMAKEN: AMERICANS PLAYING THE FOOLS

2001.10.30
SERGEI BORISOV: IN AFGHANISTAN, SOUTHERN ALLIANCE BEING FORMED

2001.11.01
SIGNS OF DISCONTENT IN US POPULATION